Independent Thinking
Working For You.

The Art of Doing Nothing

July 11, 2012

The Art of Doing Nothing

The Wall Street Journal had a great article a few weeks ago regarding a training simulation for pension plan trustees. A number of teams competed with one another and at the end of the simulation their results were analyzed to see how they performed. The analysts reviewing the results came to the conclusion that for a number of teams, what they focused on and what they should have focused on were quite often two different things.

What the participants should focus on, research analyst Nick Magnuson said, are the results over longer periods of time, and the information they had about the people, philosophy and processes of the money-management firms the pension plan trustees hired to manage their money. In most cases, it is well proven that long-term performance is “a by-product” of those aspects, Mr. Magnuson explained, while short-term results can be “noisy” and lead people astray rather than help them predict long-term results.

Yet, rather than focusing on the people and processes, the trustees playing the simulation often found it hard to resist a manager on a hot streak; at least 1/3 of the teams would dump a long-term winner in a slump and replace them with a manager going through a three year hot streak. “The ingrained patterns are too hard to break,” says Mr. Gillman, a consultant to the study group.

The key to success is being thoughtful about your decisions and then sticking with them. Participants in these investing simulations, as in the real world, tend to trade too much. After picking their initial portfolio, the winning team made the fewest trades in the group. Sometimes even no trading paid off big. “At a few contests in the past, the teams that selected their initial portfolios and then slipped out of the room to spend their time elsewhere, came back to find themselves the winners” Mr. Gillman says. “The reality is many of the teams would really be better off doing just that.”

Winning by doing nothing should be a big lesson to all investors. Select your managers carefully based on people, philosophy and process and then leave it alone. Assuming the people haven’t left and the philosophy and process are unchanged, that should be simple to do. All too often, however, it is not done.

Remember, financial markets are going to bounce up and down no matter what managers you select. Sometimes markets will be smooth for extended periods; at other times they will be frustrating and turbulent. Again, this will occur regardless of the managers you select. You cannot let your confidence in the process be derailed by the inevitable bumps in the market. There is a fine art to doing nothing. Resisting the urge to tinker once your due diligence is complete actually requires a conscious decision not to intervene at each temptation. It’s harder than it looks—and that’s often the difference between winning and losing in the long run.

It is our strong belief that to be successful in reaching your goals it is necessary to have a plan in place and to follow a process. That is, to make your life and financial decisions not by accident but by design.

Remember, successful people ACT towards the future they want!

Recent Posts

Slow & Steady Wins the Race

In North America, the majority of investors get their financial market updates from television and news media sources. Inevitably, that means over the past couple weeks your morning headlines (which...

read more

Crazy Time – Crazy Charts

It is a crazy time right now with wars, record fuel prices, supply shortages, rising interest rates, and the most overvalued housing market in the world (to name a few!). We could write paragraphs on how each of these would impact (or ultimately not impact!) your investments over the long-term, but instead, we thought this article did a great job of summing up some of the craziest charts out there right now. The link to the full article is below, however, we’ve summed it up here and added our comments to each item.

read more

Our Clients

Their honesty and customer service is right up there, with the knowledge and recommendations on where investments should be made. When it’s time for a change Tim is always honest with us on where any changes should be made.

Janet McDonald

To me, it is their personalized service. When something happens, you can go in and discuss your options. The whole team knows your plans, listens to your needs, and can help you make adjustments.

Richard Dumoulin

They are very courteous, friendly and find them very professional. They are good at taking care of time sensitive matters and you get a general sense of being taken care of.

Ginny Blair

The fact they take time to discuss with you their knowledge base, they give you all the options then give you their opinion and let YOU make the final decision.

Elisabeth 

Their integrity and 1-on-1 communication skills, always personable. Tim and his team make you feel comfortable no matter how much you are investing.

James